Oxford Style Debate on “Should we Publish in Academic Journals?”

The way research is published shapes how knowledge is used, reused and if it is trusted. There is an ongoing debate about the adequacy of the traditional academic publication system and many researchers question whether it still meets their needs. Consequently, new dissemination models are gaining attention. These alternatives are often created and led by the research communities themselves, offering fresh approaches to how scholarly work is shared. 

This session will feature an Oxford-style debate between two experts representing different publishing platforms on the future of scholarly publishing. Bernd Pulverer, Head of Scientific Publishing at EMBO Press, will make the case for the ongoing value of traditional academic publishing. EMBO Press is a well-established nonprofit publisher supported by a scholarly institution. Opposing that view, Alexandra Freeman, founder of Octopus, will advocate for fundamentally new forms of scholarly communication. Octopus is a community-driven platform that seeks to move beyond classic journal models. Each speaker will present their position on what researchers today expect from publishing—such as openness, fairness, transparency, and quality—and how different models aim to meet those expectations.

As an audience member, you will actively shape the discussion by voting on the central question both before and after the debate. The session will be moderated by Jessica Rohmann, an epidemiologist and strong advocate for rigorous research practices. Our interactive format will highlight the strengths and weaknesses of each position and the audience will play a role in shaping the future of academic publishing.

Whether you are deeply involved in scholarly publishing or simply curious about how research enters the public domain, this session offers an engaging, participatory look at a system that influences which knowledge is seen, trusted, and used, and ultimately, how the future of science, policy, and innovation is constructed.

Note: Our reserved seats have now all been taken – thank you for the great interest! But not to worry: we always keep a number of seats available for spontaneous guests. So even without a reservation, you’re very welcome to come along. And if you’d like to be notified when a spot opens up, you can sign up for our waiting list.